213800LXSV317746JZ712023-01-012023-12-31iso4217:USD213800LXSV317746JZ712022-01-012022-12-31iso4217:USDxbrli:shares213800LXSV317746JZ712023-12-31213800LXSV317746JZ712022-12-31213800LXSV317746JZ712021-12-31ifrs-full:IssuedCapitalMember213800LXSV317746JZ712021-12-31ifrs-full:SharePremiumMember213800LXSV317746JZ712021-12-31ifrs-full:MergerReserveMember213800LXSV317746JZ712021-12-31ifrs-full:RevaluationSurplusMember213800LXSV317746JZ712021-12-31ifrs-full:ReserveOfSharebasedPaymentsMember213800LXSV317746JZ712021-12-31ifrs-full:ReserveOfExchangeDifferencesOnTranslationMember213800LXSV317746JZ712021-12-31ecoraresourcesplc:SpecialReserveMember213800LXSV317746JZ712021-12-31ifrs-full:TreasurySharesMember213800LXSV317746JZ712021-12-31ecoraresourcesplc:InvestmentInOwnSharesMember213800LXSV317746JZ712021-12-31ifrs-full:RetainedEarningsMember213800LXSV317746JZ712021-12-31213800LXSV317746JZ712022-01-012022-12-31ifrs-full:IssuedCapitalMember213800LXSV317746JZ712022-01-012022-12-31ifrs-full:SharePremiumMember213800LXSV317746JZ712022-01-012022-12-31ifrs-full:MergerReserveMember213800LXSV317746JZ712022-01-012022-12-31ifrs-full:RevaluationSurplusMember213800LXSV317746JZ712022-01-012022-12-31ifrs-full:ReserveOfSharebasedPaymentsMember213800LXSV317746JZ712022-01-012022-12-31ifrs-full:ReserveOfExchangeDifferencesOnTranslationMember213800LXSV317746JZ712022-01-012022-12-31ecoraresourcesplc:SpecialReserveMember213800LXSV317746JZ712022-01-012022-12-31ifrs-full:TreasurySharesMember213800LXSV317746JZ712022-01-012022-12-31ecoraresourcesplc:InvestmentInOwnSharesMember213800LXSV317746JZ712022-01-012022-12-31ifrs-full:RetainedEarningsMember213800LXSV317746JZ712022-12-31ifrs-full:IssuedCapitalMember213800LXSV317746JZ712022-12-31ifrs-full:SharePremiumMember213800LXSV317746JZ712022-12-31ifrs-full:MergerReserveMember213800LXSV317746JZ712022-12-31ifrs-full:RevaluationSurplusMember213800LXSV317746JZ712022-12-31ifrs-full:ReserveOfSharebasedPaymentsMember213800LXSV317746JZ712022-12-31ifrs-full:ReserveOfExchangeDifferencesOnTranslationMember213800LXSV317746JZ712022-12-31ecoraresourcesplc:SpecialReserveMember213800LXSV317746JZ712022-12-31ifrs-full:TreasurySharesMember213800LXSV317746JZ712022-12-31ecoraresourcesplc:InvestmentInOwnSharesMember213800LXSV317746JZ712022-12-31ifrs-full:RetainedEarningsMember213800LXSV317746JZ712023-01-012023-12-31ifrs-full:IssuedCapitalMember213800LXSV317746JZ712023-01-012023-12-31ifrs-full:SharePremiumMember213800LXSV317746JZ712023-01-012023-12-31ifrs-full:MergerReserveMember213800LXSV317746JZ712023-01-012023-12-31ifrs-full:RevaluationSurplusMember213800LXSV317746JZ712023-01-012023-12-31ifrs-full:ReserveOfSharebasedPaymentsMember213800LXSV317746JZ712023-01-012023-12-31ifrs-full:ReserveOfExchangeDifferencesOnTranslationMember213800LXSV317746JZ712023-01-012023-12-31ecoraresourcesplc:SpecialReserveMember213800LXSV317746JZ712023-01-012023-12-31ifrs-full:TreasurySharesMember213800LXSV317746JZ712023-01-012023-12-31ecoraresourcesplc:InvestmentInOwnSharesMember213800LXSV317746JZ712023-01-012023-12-31ifrs-full:RetainedEarningsMember213800LXSV317746JZ712023-12-31ifrs-full:IssuedCapitalMember213800LXSV317746JZ712023-12-31ifrs-full:SharePremiumMember213800LXSV317746JZ712023-12-31ifrs-full:MergerReserveMember213800LXSV317746JZ712023-12-31ifrs-full:RevaluationSurplusMember213800LXSV317746JZ712023-12-31ifrs-full:ReserveOfSharebasedPaymentsMember213800LXSV317746JZ712023-12-31ifrs-full:ReserveOfExchangeDifferencesOnTranslationMember213800LXSV317746JZ712023-12-31ecoraresourcesplc:SpecialReserveMember213800LXSV317746JZ712023-12-31ifrs-full:TreasurySharesMember213800LXSV317746JZ712023-12-31ecoraresourcesplc:InvestmentInOwnSharesMember213800LXSV317746JZ712023-12-31ifrs-full:RetainedEarningsMember
Investing in
the present,
changing
thefuture
Ecora Resources PLC
Annual Report and Accounts 2023
Ecora Resources PLCAnnual Report and Accounts 2023
We are a leading royalty company focused
on supporting the supply ofcommodities
essential to creating asustainable future.
Alternative performance measures
Throughout this report a number of
financial measures are used to assess
the Groups performance. The measures
are defined below and, with the
exception of operating profit/(loss),
arenon-IFRS measures because they
exclude amounts that are included in, or
include amounts that are excluded from,
the most directly comparable measure
calculated and presented in accordance
with IFRS, or are calculated using financial
measures that are not calculated in
accordance with IFRS. The non-IFRS
measures may not be comparable to
other similarly titled measures used
byother companies and have limitations
as analytical tools and should not be
considered in isolation or as a substitute
for analysis of the Group’s operating
results as reported under IFRS. The
Group does not regard these non-IFRS
measures as a substitute for, orsuperior
to, the equivalent measures calculated
and presented in accordance with IFRS
or those calculated using financial
measures that are calculated in
accordance with IFRS.
Portfolio contribution Portfolio
contribution reflects the underlying
performance of the Group’s assets
both in terms of those already in
production and the timing of the
Group’s development royalties
cominginto production.
Portfolio contribution is royalty and
stream-related revenue (refer to note
5) plus royalties received or receivable
from royalty financial instruments
carried at fair value through profit or
loss (‘FVTPL’) and principal repayment
received under the Denison financing
agreement (refer to note 22). Refer to
note 36 to the financial statements
forportfolio contribution.
Operating profit/(loss) Operating
profit/(loss) represents the Group’s
underlying operating performance
from its royalty and stream interests.
Operating profit/(loss) is royalty
income, less amortisation of royalties
and operating expenses, and excludes
impairments, revaluations and gain/
(loss) on disposals. Operating profit/
(loss) reconciles to ‘operating profit/
(loss) before impairments, revaluations
and gains/(losses) on disposals’ in
theincome statement.
Adjusted earnings per share
Adjusted earnings represents the
Group’s underlying operating
performance from core activities.
Adjusted earnings is the profit/ (loss)
attributable to equity holders, plus
royalties received from royalty financial
instruments carried at fair value
through profit or loss, less all valuation
movements and impairments (which
are non-cash adjustments that arise
primarily due to changes in commodity
prices), together with amortisation
charges, foreign exchange gains/
(losses), any associated deferred
taxand any profit or loss on
non-coreasset disposals.
Adjusted earnings divided by the
weighted average number of shares
inissue gives adjusted earnings per
share. Refer to note 12 to the
financialstatements for adjusted
earnings/(loss) per share.
Dividend cover Dividend cover is
calculated as the number of times
adjusted earnings per share exceeds
the dividend per share. Refer to note
13 to the financial statements for
dividend cover.
Free cash flow per share Free cash
flow per share is calculated by dividing
net cash generated from operating
activities, plus proceeds from the
disposal of non-core assets and any
cash considered as repayment of
principal, less finance costs, by the
weighted average number of shares in
issue. Refer to note35 to the financial
statements for free cash flow pershare.
Strategic report
1 Our purpose
2
Highlights
4
Ecora at a glance
6
Our portfolio
8
Our markets
12
Chairman’s statement
14
Investment case
16
Chief Executive Officers statement
18
Our business model
20
Our strategy
22
Key performance indicators
24
Supporting a sustainable future
26
Business review
42
Financial review
47
Section 172(1) statement
48
Our stakeholders
50
Sustainability
60
Risk management
62
Emerging risks
63
Principal risks
68
Task Force on Climate-related
FinancialDisclosures
82
Viability Statement
Governance report
83 Corporate governance
92
Board of Directors
94
Nomination Committee
96
Audit Committee
101
Sustainability Committee
103
Remuneration Committee
109
Directors’ remuneration policy
116
Annual Remuneration Report for 2023
124
Directors’ report
128
Statement of Directors’ responsibilities
Financial statements
129 Independent auditor’s report to the
members of Ecora Resources PLC
136
Consolidated income statement
137
Consolidated statement
ofcomprehensive income
138
Consolidated balance sheet
andCompany balance sheet
139
Consolidated statement of changes
inequity
140
Company statement of changes in equity
141
Consolidated statement of cash flows
and Company statement of cash flows
142
Notes to the consolidated
financialstatements
Other information
195 Shareholder statistics
196 Other information
197 Forward looking statements
Investing in the
present, changing
the future
Discover more
online:
Our purpose
Providing capital to the mining sector required to
supplythecommoditiescentral to a sustainable future.
Our strategy
Portfolio diversification
We seek diversity of commodities,
jurisdiction and asset maturity to
balance portfolio risk.
Commodity selection
Our focus is on providing investors
withexposure to commodities that
willsupport a sustainable future and
makinginvestments in line with our
investment criteria.
Capital allocation
We balance investing for growth,
maintaining a strong balance sheet
withproviding a royalty sector leading
dividend yield.
Our sustainability summary
Science Based Target
initiative (SBTi)
SBTi approved emissions targets.
UN Global Compact
Submitted our first Communication on
Progress (COP).
Improved ratings
MSCI rating improved to AA (fromA).
Sustainalytics rating 12.3(lowrisk).
Our values
Sustainability
We believe long-term
valuecan only be achieved
throughsustainable and
responsibleinvestment.
Integrity
We promote transparency
and build trust through
honest relationships.
Respect and inclusion
We create an environment
where everyone is seen,
heard, valued and
empowered tosucceed.
Collaboration
We believe teamwork is
essential to achieving our
vision and delivering value
toour stakeholders.
Read more on p20
Read more on p52
Read more on p52
1Ecora Resources PLC Annual Report and Accounts 2023
Strategic report Governance report Financial statements
Results in line
with expectations
Financial highlights
Free cash flow ($’m)
$29.7m (-77%)
‘23
‘22
21
‘20
‘19
29.7
132.1
48.4
25.4
61.0
Dividend per share*
8.5c (n/c)
‘23
‘22
21
‘20
‘19
8.5c
7.0p
7.0p
9.0p
9.0p
Portfolio contribution ($m)
$63.6m (-56)%
‘23
‘22
21
‘20
‘19
63.6
143.2
85.6
47.5
75.9
Royalty assets acquired ($’m)
$27.5m (-85%)
‘23
‘22
21
‘20
‘19
27.5
185.0
207.7
9.8
75.8
Adjusted earnings per share
11.82c (-69%)
Royalty and metal stream-related revenue ($’m)
$61.9m (-56%)
‘23
‘23
‘22
‘22
21
21
‘20
‘20
‘19
‘19
11.82c
61.9
37.55p
141.9
25.18p
85.3
15.69p
43.7
26.06p
71.2
Dividend cover (x)
1.4x (-68%)
Profit before tax ($’m)
$4.5m (-97%)
‘23
‘22
‘22
21
21
‘20
‘20
‘19
‘19
1.4
4.5
4.4
135.4
2.6
54.6
1.4
(34.9)
2.3
48.1
HIGHLIGHTS
Read more on pages 42 to 46
‘23
* Dividends were paid in GBp until 2023 when the Group started to pay dividends in USc.
2 Ecora Resources PLC Annual Report and Accounts 2023
Science Based Targets
initiative(SBTi)
During 2023 the SBTi for small to medium sized businesses
approved Ecora’s target of reducingScope 1 and 2 GHG
emissions 46% by 2030 from the baseline year of 2019,
and to measure and reduce its Scope 3 emissions.
Portfolio and sustainability highlights
Improved MSCI and
Sustainalytics score
During the year the Groups MSCI rating improved from
Ato AA, and Sustainalytics score improved to 12.3,
ratingEcora as low risk.
12.3
Sustainalytics score
Vizcachitas royalty acquisition
Acquired a 0.25% Net Smelter Return royalty over all
metal production from the open pit of the Vizcachitas
copper project in Chile. A rare opportunity toacquire
aroyalty over one of the world’s largest undeveloped
copper projects located in a well-established
miningjurisdiction.
LIORC disposal
The Group sold ~60% of its holding in the Labrador Iron
Ore Royalty Company. This realised C$18.9m, a gain on
disposal of C$4.1m and representing a total pre-tax
return on investment of c. 110%.
Four Mile legal resolution
A favourable judgment was delivered by the Supreme
Court of Western Australia, Court of Appeal in Ecora’s
legal dispute with Quasar Resources Pty Ltd, the owner
and operator of the Four Mile uranium mine. This saw
A$9.3m released to the income statement in Q4 2023.
A$9.3m
released to income statement
Read more on p53 Read more on p50
~$20m
purchase consideration
110%
pre-tax return on investment
Read more on p29
Read more on p38
Piauí investment
Invested $7.5m to increase our royalty over Brazilian
Nickel’s nickel-cobalt project by 0.35% to 1.60%.
Ecorahas the right to acquire a further 2.65% royalty
for$62.5m.
$7.5m
Read more on p33
Read more on p37
3Ecora Resources PLC Annual Report and Accounts 2023
Strategic report Governance report Financial statements
Our portfolio
What we do
Our vision is to be globally recognised
asthe royalty company of choice
synonymous with commodities that
support a sustainable future by
continuing to grow and diversify our
royalty portfolio in line with our strategy.
We will achieve this through building
adiversified portfolio of scale over
highquality assets that drives low
volatility earnings growth and
shareholder returns.
Our strategy is to acquire royalties and
streams over low cost operations and
projects with strong management teams,
in well-established mining jurisdictions.
Our portfolio has been re-weighted to
provide material exposure to this
commodity basket and we have
successfully transitioned from a coal
orientated royalty business in 2014 to
one that by 2026 will be materially coal
free and comprise over 90% exposure to
commodities that support a sustainable
future. The fundamental demand
outlook for these commodities over the
next decade is very strong, which should
significantly increase the value of our
royalty portfolio.
How we do it
Royalties explained
A natural resources royalty is a non-
operating interest in a project that
provides the royalty holder with the
rightto a percentage of the revenues
generated from the extraction and sale
of minerals from a specified area
ofinterest. Aroyalty holder is not
generally obligated tocontribute
towardsoperating or capital costs,
norenvironmental or reclamation
liabilities. A primary royalty is entered
into when the royalty company makes
anup-front cash payment to the
mineoperator in return for a royalty.
Asecondary royalty is an existing royalty
that is acquired directly from the owner
of the royalty.
Streams explained
A metal stream is an agreement that
provides, in exchange for an upfront
payment, the right to purchase all or a
portion of one or more metals produced
from a mine. Streams, whilst providing
asimilar outcome for Ecora, are not
royalties because they do not constitute
an interest in land and there is an
ongoing cash payment required to
purchase the physical metal. However,
astream holder is not ordinarily required
to contribute towards operating or
capital costs, nor environmental or
reclamation liabilities.
Portfolio –
diversifiedexposure*
* Based on consensus sell side analyst NAV estimates
as at 22 March 2024
Geographic exposure*
USA & Canada 32%
Brazil & Chile 41%
Australia 26%
Other 1%
95%
of the portfolio in
OECD countries
Commodity exposure*
Base metals 75%
Uranium 5%
Vanadium 5%
Steelmaking coal 8%
Other 7%
88%
of the portfolio is
future facing
Stage of production*
Producing 53%
In construction 16%
Development 27%
Early-stage 4%
53%
of the portfolio is
producing
ECORA AT A GLANCE
Read more on p22
4 Ecora Resources PLC Annual Report and Accounts 2023
21
principal royalty and
streaming‑relatedassets
5
continents
10
commodities
Geography – our global OECD footprint*
Markets – pathways toasustainable future
Aligned with four key thematics:
* Based on sell side analyst consensus as at 28 February 2024
1. Operations
with robust
sustainability
profiles
3. Energy
transmission
2. Low carbon
energy
generation
4. Energy
consumption
Read more on p28
Read more on p18
32%
USA & Canada
41%
Brazil & Chile
26%
Australia
5Ecora Resources PLC Annual Report and Accounts 2023
Strategic report Governance report Financial statements
Exposure to world-class
operators
Royalties cover mining operations run by some
of the largest mining companies in the world.
OUR PORTFOLIO
Base metals
Asset Commodity Location Development stage
Operator/
developer Royalty basis Mine life See more
1
Mantos Blancos Copper Chile Producing Capstone Copper 1.525% NSR 2038 p27
2
Carlota Copper US Producing KGHM 5.0% NSR 2024/2025 p30
3
West Musgrave Nickel and copper Australia In construction BHP 2.0% NSR 24 years p32
4
Santo Domingo Copper and cobalt Chile Development Capstone Copper 2.0% NSR 18 years p28
5
Piauí Nickel and cobalt Brazil Development Brazilian Nickel 1.60% GRR 18 years p33
6
Vizcachitas Copper Chile Development Los Andes Copper 1% NSR 26 years p29
7
Nifty Copper Australia Development Cyprium 1.5% GRR 15 years p30
8
Cañariaco Copper and gold Peru Early stage Candente Copper 0.5% NSR 28 years p31
Speciality and battery metals
Asset Commodity Location Development stage
Operator/
developer Royalty basis Mine life See more
9
Voisey’s Bay Cobalt Canada Producing Vale 22.82% stream 2035 p34
10
Maracás Menchen Vanadium Brazil Producing Largo Resources 2.0% NSR 2041 p35
Uranium
Asset Commodity Location Development stage
Operator/
developer Royalty basis Mine life See more
11
McClean Lake mill Uranium Canada Producing Orano
22.5% of toll
millingrevenue
2037 p36
12
Four Mile Uranium Australia Producing Quasar Resources 1.0% NSR 2029 p37
13
Salamanca Uranium Spain Development Berkeley Energia 1.0% NSR 14 years p37
14
SW2 Uranium Canada Early stage NexGen 2.0% NSR n/a p37
6 Ecora Resources PLC Annual Report and Accounts 2023
Visit www.ecora-resources.com/our-portfolio
Lower impact bulks
Asset Commodity Location Development stage
Operator/
developer Royalty basis Mine life See more
15
IOC Iron ore Canada Producing Rio Tinto 7.0% GRR (indirect) 2045 p38
16
Pilbara Iron ore Australia Early stage BHP 1.5% GRR N/A p39
17
Incoa Calcium carbonate
Dominican
Republic/US
Development Incoa ~1.23% GRR N/A p39
18
Ring of Fire Chromite Canada Early stage Wyloo Metals 1.0% NSR N/A p39
Other
Asset Commodity Location Development stage
Operator/
developer Royalty basis Mine life See more
19
Kestrel Steelmaking coal Australia Producing
EMR Capital and
Adaro
7.0–40.0% GRR 2026
(1)
p40
20
EVBC Gold Spain Producing Orvana Minerals 2.5–3.0% NSR 2026 p41
21
Dugbe 1 Gold Liberia Early stage Pasofino Gold 2-2.5% NSR 14 years
6
7
9
1
16
4
10
2
19
11
8
13
15
17
3
5
12
Mine locations
Key
 Base metals
 Speciality and battery metals
 Uranium
 Lower impact bulks
 Other
18
20
21
14
Strategic report Governance report Financial statements
7Ecora Resources PLC Annual Report and Accounts 2023
An overview ofour markets
Royalty financing continued its role in bridging the capital gap to the mining
sector during 2023. Capital markets remained very challenging globally,
with equity markets generally depressed, few IPOs launched, and credit
conditions tightened particularly in the second half of the year.
1
Catastrophic and natural
catastrophic risk
2
Investment approval
3
Future demand
4
Commodity prices
5
Operator dependence
and concentration risk
6
Geopolitical events
7
Financing capability
8
Stakeholder support
Key to strategy
Commodity selection
Investment framework
Portfoliodiversification
Capital allocation
OUR MARKETS
The cost of capital in the sector,
combined with the increased
requirement for capital after two years
ofgenerationally high levels of inflation,
resulted in an increased pressure on
smaller operators in the sector. The
collapse in equity ratings for less liquid
stocks, along with the significantly higher
cost of debt (if available) resulted in an
increased demand for alternative forms
of financing. This resulted in ~$2.2bn of
royalty and stream transactions during
the year. This dynamic looks set to
continue in 2024, as equity markets
generally remain tough, interest rates
arelikely to remain higher for longer.
Thelatter has resulted in reduced
valuations for development projects in
particular as future cash flows continue
to be discounted at a higher level.
Within the mining universe, base metal
and bulk commodities suffer more as
precious metal projects tend to have
lower capex costs and shorter
development time horizons. Furthermore,
the precious metals sector tends to
benefit from more favourable equity
ratings both at operator level and at
royalty company level. It was no surprise
therefore that of the $2.2bn of royalty
and stream transactions executed during
the year ~83% of these were in the
precious space.
Competition within the precious space
has remained high, most noticeably in
the sub $1bn market capitalisation range
where a number of junior royalty
companies compete for smaller ticket
size acquisitions. For this reason, the
Group chooses to focus on the non-
precious space where fewer companies
compete for the same transaction and
access to capital is making the deal
environment more favourable.
Within this subsector, pricing for certain
commodities has corrected noticeably
for certain commodities such as lithium,
nickel and cobalt. Other than for lithium,
the nickel market has been disrupted by
the recent and sudden supply increase
from Indonesia which has created a
market imbalance with greater supply
and pricing has fallen accordingly. This is
placing margin pressure on many
previously profitable nickel operations,
with some shutting (noticeably in
Australia) and others revisiting their
capital requirements. Declining
commodity environments like this can
lead to increased demand for royalty and
streaming financing which is less dilutive
than equity and less intrusive than debt,
which can enable smaller operators to
weather a downturn in the price cycle.
Conversely, for royalty and streaming
businesses, this represents a much
morefavourable price entry point
against a backdrop of favourable
investment conditions.
In terms of M&A activities, some of the
larger non-precious operators have
begun to diversify more into future
facing commodities. We have seen BHP
acquire Oz Minerals, Glencore and Teck
Resources agree a business combination
on coal assets and Rio Tinto
consolidating its stake over their
Mongolian copper project. This wave of
M&A activity by the majors could well
continue in the years ahead as they
leverage their size and access to capital.
An active M&A environment is also a
favourable backdrop for royalty and
streaming businesses as this creates
aneed for liquidity.
As is always the case for the natural
resource sector, demand is key. In this
respect a slow down in the Chinese
economy coupled with two serious
international conflicts creates a lot of
uncertainty for domestic policies such as
those around compulsory adopting of
electric vehicles and transition timelines
and commitments to net zero. This saw a
reduction in demand for electric vehicles
in certain markets in 2023 which
coincided with a moment of additional
supply for key battery commodities.
However, lower commodity prices are
likely to make certain battery chemistries
more economical with the potential of
lowering the cost of adoption – which in
its own right could trigger renewed
demand in future periods.
For the royalty and streaming
businesses, particularly those investing
outside of the precious space, the pull
back in pricing experienced over the past
twelve months arguably presents an
opportune investment point which can
result in significant value accruing should
markets return to supply demand
equilibrium in the near-term.
Key to principal risks
8 Ecora Resources PLC Annual Report and Accounts 2023
Cobalt
Rising supply and subdued demand negatively
impacted the price performance of cobalt in 2023.
Cobalt is predominantly produced as a by-product of
copper and nickel mining, and rapid growth in nickel
production from Indonesia led to a market awash
with readily available supply. A number of Indonesian
nickel laterite deposits - supported largely by Chinese
operators - have come online faster than many
observers had expected.
Despite the rise of Indonesian supply, the Democratic
Republic of Congo (DRC) remains the primary source
of cobalt. Logistical bottlenecks seen in 2022 eased,
while the successful ramp-up of the Kisanfu copper
mine, and the lifting of export restrictions at Tenke
Fungurume led to greater availability of supply.
Growing demand from battery producers was limited
as a number of electric-vehicle manufacturers either
tempered their sale forecasts, or opted for cobalt-free
battery chemistries. Demand from the stainless steel
market remained robust despite slow global growth.
Cobalt hydroxide prices from the DRC negatively
weighed on the cobalt metal price throughout the
second half of the year, with alloy grade material
trading rangebound between $16-19/lb. The price of
cobalt metal (alloy grade) finished the year at $16/lb,
down 27% from the start of the year.
Ecora impact:
n Ecora would consider increasing its existing cobalt
exposure should there be an opportunity at an
attractive entry point.
Copper
A number of supply shocks over 2023 flipped
expectations of an upcoming surplus to a near term
shortage of supply.
Notable hits to supply towards the end of the year
included the cessation of mining activities at one of
the worlds largest mines, Cobre Panama, operated by
First Quantum. Guidance was slashed at a number of
other high profile producers, namely Anglo American,
Rio Tinto, Vale and Boliden amongst others.
These reductions did not materially move the price of
copper however, which traded between $3.55-3.99/lb
over the second half of the year as the market
remained wary of China’s structural challenges and
slowing global demand drivers. Further factors
curtailing copper demand were the
strength of the US
dollar, and rising global interest rates.
The backdrop for copper prices going forward
appears promising as global economies drive for
increased electrification at a time of shrinking supply
and lower grade profiles of existing mines. Bringing
additional supply online is further hampered by
increased permitting hurdles, rising costs and difficult
geological settings.
The copper price finished 2023 at $3.84/lb, up 1%
from the start of the year, and averaged $3.85/lb.
Ecora impact:
n The long term market outlook remains positive and
Ecora will look to continue adding further copper
royalties to the portfolio.
Link to strategy
Linktoprincipalrisks
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Link to strategy
Linktoprincipalrisks
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9Ecora Resources PLC Annual Report and Accounts 2023
Strategic report Governance report Financial statements
OUR MARKETS CONTINUED
Nickel
Growth of large capacity projects in Indonesia was
responsible for a 45% fall in the price of LME nickel
in2023.
Market tightness at the end of 2022 evaporated as
Chinese producers took advantage of high prices to
convert intermediate nickel products from Indonesia
into class 1 nickel suitable for trading on the LME.
Thisled to a rapid restocking of inventories during the
second half of 2023, increasing by approximately 75%.
The pace of electric vehicle adoption has slowed
compared to expectations which has led Western
manufacturers (who typically favour energy-dense,
nickel based battery chemistries) to push back sales
targets. Asian manufacturers have also tended to opt
for battery chemistries absent nickel and cobalt which
has dampened near-term demand for the metal.
Growth in stainless steel production and nickel use in
electric vehicle batteries both increased year on year,
but it was not enough to offset the rapid increase in
supply. Prices have subsequently weakened further
inearly 2024, causing higher cost producers to cease
operations. Prices will likely continue to trade into the
cost curve until such time that enough supply has
been curtailed, or demand catches up.
The nickel price finished 2023 at $7.43/lb,
andaveraged $9.75/lb.
Ecora impact:
n Continue to focus on nickel projects such as
WestMusgrave and Piauí which are low on the
costcurve.
n West Musgrave project will potentially see the
operator review phasing of capital expenditure.
n Bottom of cycle prices could represent an
interesting point of entry for new royalties.
Link to strategy
Linktoprincipalrisks
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Steel-making coal
Steel-making coal, or metallurgical coal, was one of
the top performing commodities of 2023, closing
above $320/t, up 12% over the course of the year.
The record high prices of 2022 following Russia’s
invasion of Ukraine tempered somewhat,
butremained elevated throughout the year.
Pricesbottomed in Q2 and Q3 as optimism faded
from an expected rise in demand linked to China’s
reopening, but still remained well above the rolling
five year average. Robust demand from China and
India, as well as supply concerns from Australian
producers (linked to technical issues and turbulent
weather patterns), then led to a price rally towards
the end of 2023.
Indian imports have offset weakness from European
markets where the steel industry has struggled in
thelight of elevated energy costs, lower demand
anda shift towards less carbon intensive forms of
steelmaking. China’s steel output has remained
robust despite the continued domestic property
slowdown, with high blast-furnace utilisation as scrap
metal became harder to find.
Near-term conditions appear supportive of current
prices, but supply is forecast to pick up as technical
issues are resolved and weather disruptions in
Australia subside. The steel-making coal price
averaged $291/t throughout 2023.
Ecora impact:
n The current price environment for steelmaking
coalis driving material portfolio contribution
fromthe Kestrel royalty.
n There are no plans to invest additional capital into
steelmaking coal.
Link to strategy
Linktoprincipalrisks
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
10 Ecora Resources PLC Annual Report and Accounts 2023
Other
Iron ore shrugged off concerns of a faltering Chinese
economy and continued weakness in the property
market to rise 18% during 2023.
Low margins at Chinese steel mills ensured iron ore
required in blast furnaces was preferred to the
difficult-to-source scrap metal used in electric-arc
furnaces. Blast furnace utilisation throughout the
year was approximately 80%, near 2020 peak levels.
62% iron ore averaged $114/t during 2023, and
finished the year at $132/t.
Vanadium is a key material in steel-making,
specifically used to increase strength and durability.
Ithas a rising end-market use in vanadium redox
batteries, which is a growing battery type for
stationary storage. The price of vanadium peaked at
$10.80/lb in February, before falling to $6.53/lb at the
end of the year. The average vanadium price over the
period was $8.34/lb.
Ecora impact:
n Continue to look at opportunities in commodities
such as rare earths, graphite, lithium, zinc, tin and
high purity manganese that would round out the
commodity basket.
Uranium
Uranium continues to benefit from improving global
sentiment towards nuclear energy and security of
power supply.
Uranium prices went from strength to strength
during2023 as governments backed nuclear energy
as a source of low-carbon and reliable power.
Utilitieswere focused on security of uranium
supplyas question marks remained over the future
accessibility of Russian material, as well as production
shortfalls in Kazakhstan and a coup in Niger.
Supplyisnotoriously difficult to bring on line,
andwith historically low investments in greenfield
and brownfield deposits since the Fukushima
disasterin 2011, utilities looked to shore up their
inventories throughout the year.
Uranium is usually traded in the form of long term
contracts; however, the scramble for supply has
required market participants to be more active in
thespot market – pushing spot prices above $100/lb
in early 2024. The average price for spot material in
2023 was $62.50/lb, 25% higher than the average
price in 2022.
Ecora impact:
n Elevated prices should, over time, translate into
increased revenue from the Four Mile royalty.
n Higher prices could accelerate development of
previously idle deposits.
Link to strategy
Linktoprincipalrisks
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Link to strategy
Linktoprincipalrisks
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
11Ecora Resources PLC Annual Report and Accounts 2023
Strategic report Governance report Financial statements
2023 was a year of mixed fortunes for the markets in which
we operate. Having enjoyed relatively buoyant conditions
in the wake of the pandemic, the economic outlook has
beenaffectedbythefightagainstinflationandthe
resultant higher interest rates. At the same time Chinas
economy has been less robust than we have seen in recent
years which has dampened demand for some key raw
materials,andcontinuedgeopoliticaltensionsandconflicts
give cause for concern.
Having benefitted from record prices in our commodity mix in
2022, we saw some easing during 2023. This has led to lower
prices for some commodities such as cobalt, while steelmaking
coal has fallen even though it continues to trade at historically
high levels. In turn, this has led to lower earnings at a more
sustainable level than in 2022.
We remain committed to the transition we have undertaken in
our portfolio towards those commodities which are critical for
decarbonisation and are very excited at the quality and future
potential that our current portfolio offers. We are seeing a
slower rate of the growth in demand for some areas such as
electric vehicles but the pace is still extremely strong and the
medium- and long-term direction of travel is clearly set as the
imperative of tackling climate change intensifies.
We will continue to build the portfolio with strong value-accretive
transactions and are hopeful that the current economic and
market pressures experienced by the mining sector will offer
useven better opportunities to deploy capital.
I am writing to you for the final time as Chairman of Ecora
Resources and it is perhaps worth reflecting that back in 2015,
the Company was really a play on a single royalty, over the
Kestrel steel making coal mine, that had around ten years of
income contribution left. The two major strategic challenges
toaddress were the overdependence on one asset and the
need to diversify the commodity base whilst orientating
towards future facing commodities.
“The Company is in a
strong position and has
an exciting future ahead
Patrick Meier
Chairman
CHAIRMAN’S STATEMENT
Under the management of Marc Bishop Lafleche, the team
hascompleted several transactions that are expected to
replace the Kestrel income and developed the royalty sector
leading copper exposure. The portfolio now offers material
income growth over the coming years.
To put this into context, in 2015 our royalty income was $13.6m,
73% of our NAV was in coal, net assets totalled $240m and we
had a $30m borrowing facility. Compare this to 2023, with
royalty income of $61.9m, 85% of our NAV now in future facing
commodities, net assets totaling $482m and a borrowing
capacity of $225m. Whilst this transformation has not been
reflected in the share price, I have every confidence that this
value will be realised in the coming years as the development
projects hit production and start to deliver income for
theCompany.
Beyond the asset portfolio, there has also been considerable
change within the Company over the last few years. The Board
has completely transitioned, and we have built a team of highly
experienced, capable individuals. We have strengthened the
wider team in key functions within the business such as legal,
finance and investor relations, reflecting the increased maturity
of the Company. I am also pleased to say that we have
developed a Governance framework that is fit for our business,
and despite not being a premium listed company, have upheld
the corporate governance standards of such a company. Finally,
we responded in 2020 to the increased focus on sustainability
by establishing a Sustainability Committee that has driven
improvements in our processes and disclosures in this area.
Board and governance
Following a thorough recruitment process, we were delighted to
announce the appointment of Andrew Webb as non-executive
director and Chair designate in January. Andrew has a wealth of
experience as an advisor to the mining sector from his role as a
Managing Director of Rothschild & Sons. He is already proving
that he will be a valuable addition to the Board. I wish him all
the very best in the role and I am sure he will work well with
theBoard, Marc and the rest of the team to drive the
Companyforward.
12 Ecora Resources PLC Annual Report and Accounts 2023
Chair Designate
In January 2024 the Board appointed Andrew Webb
as an independent Non-Executive Director and Chair
designate. Andrew will succeed Patrick Meier as
Chair at the Annual General Meeting in May 2024.
“As Chair Designate, I would like to say how excited I
am to be joining the Board of Ecora Resources. In my
career at Rothschild as an adviser to the mining
sector, I have followed the Company for many years.
The management team has successfully created a
diversified royalty company with a strong
foundation for growth over the coming years. As the
world continues the energy transition, there will
need to be a substantial increase in the quantity of
base metals andother future facing commodities
that are being mined, and this will create further
opportunities for Ecora to build on its sector
leading, non-precious
metals royalty portfolio.
Finally, I would like to thank
Patrick Meier for his
leadership over the past
few years and say how
much I am looking forward
to working with the team
tocontinue to deliver long
term shareholder value.
(1) Free cash flow is calculated as net cash generated from operating
activities, plus proceeds from the disposal of non-core assets
andrepayments received under commodity related financing
arrangements, less finance costs and lease payments.
Stakeholder engagement
During the year we continued to engage with our key
stakeholders and more information can be found on page 47 in
our Section 172 Statement. In terms of shareholders, we have
run proactive engagement programmes with both institutional
and retail investors in the UK, Europe, Australia and North
America. We have further expanded the sell side research
coverage in the UK, and this will continue to be an area of focus
in 2024. We have continued to build closer relationships with
our operators and communities and were pleased to co-invest
with Vale in our first community initiative at Voisey’s Bay. On
behalf of the Board, I would like to thank all our stakeholders
foryour continued support.
Thanks
Finally, I would like to sign off by thanking the Ecora team for all
of its support over the past nine years, and its ongoing hard
work and dedication. The Company has changed beyond
recognition since I first joined – as a team, we have overcome
hurdles and achieved our key strategic objectives. I am
confident that the foundations are now in place and the
Company has an exciting future ahead.
Patrick Meier
Chairman
26 March 2024
The Board continues to execute its role in both challenging and
supporting the management team in pursuit of the Company’s
strategy. An integral part of the Board’s focus is to ensure we
operate with integrity and to the highest ethical standards; our
commitment to sustainability forms an important part of this.
The Board is constantly seeking to improve its effectiveness and
during 2023 completed an independent Board effectiveness
evaluation. More detail on the process can befound on pages
87 to 90, but to summarisetheBoard was found to function
well, with some areas for improvement highlighted which we will
address. Moreinformation on the operation and activities of
the Board can be found on pages 83 to 93.
Capital allocation
The Group moved to paying fixed dividends in US dollars in
2023 with a quarterly dividend of 2.125c per share, resulting
inan annual dividend of 8.5c per share.
The Board has reviewed the company’s approach to capital
allocation and has approved an updated framework which
aimsto maintain balance sheet strength, provide an attractive
dividend yield relative to the wider royalty sector, and retain the
flexibility to allocate capital to enhance the Company’s royalty
portfolio via accretive royalty acquisitions. The approach will
also align dividend payout to free cash flow which is expected
togrow as near-term development royalties come online.
Ecora’s updated capital allocation framework has four pillars:
n Acquire high-quality royalties to further diversify and grow
our portfolio.
n Focus on post-transaction balance sheet deleveraging.
n Distribute semi-annual cash dividends based on a range
of25-35% of free cash flow
(1)
n Consider share buybacks in the context of market price and
net asset value
Based on research analyst consensus commodity price
forecasts and operator production volume guidance from
Ecora’s operating partners, the mid-point of the new dividend
payout ratio would see total FY 2024 dividend of approximately
4.0c per share.
The updated dividend arrangements will take effect for the 2024
financial year, starting with the H1 2024 dividend which will be
declared in September 2024 and will be payable in January 2025.
The Board has decided that at the current market valuation a
share buyback represents a compelling investment opportunity
and has therefore approved a $10m share buyback programme
to commence immediately. This majority of this will be funded
from the proceeds of the partial sale of our stake in Labrador
Iron Ore Royalty Corporation in Q4 2023.
13Ecora Resources PLC Annual Report and Accounts 2023
Strategic report Governance report Financial statements
Attractive
growth profile
Our portfolio of royalties in future
facing commodities has the
potential to grow from generating
$27m of portfolio contribution in
2023 to generating over $100m
ofannual portfolio contribution
inthe medium term.
Portfolio contribution ($m)
Future facing contribution
Other
Compelling
commodity mix
We provide investors with access
to a commodity mix that contains
minerals and metals such as
copper, cobalt and nickel that will
be needed in increased quantity
ifthesupply is to meet expected
demand growth driven bythe
energytransition.
High quality
partners
We invest the majority of capital
into low cost mines primarily
located in OECD jurisdictions
thatare operated by companies
including Vale, Capstone Copper,
BHP and Rio Tinto.
Operators
* Based on consensus forecasts of covering sell side analysts
Copper
Cobalt
Nickel
Vanadium
Uranium
INVESTMENT CASE
Positioned to deliver
sustainable income
growth
We offer investors exposure to a basket ofcommodities
that are integral to the energytransition.
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
23 24 25 Medium
term
Read more on p6 Read more on p8
Read more on p26
14 Ecora Resources PLC Annual Report and Accounts 2023
Balance sheet
flexibility
We refinanced our debt facility in
early 2024, increasing the potential
borrowing capacity to $225m.
Furthermore, we have announced
a capital allocation framework
thatappropriately balances
deleveraging, growth and
shareholder returns.
Strong
sustainability
framework
All potential investments are
screened against our extensive
sustainability criteria before
wecommit to the transaction.
Weconduct ongoing monitoring
ofall of our portfolio investments
to make sure the operations
continue to meet our ESG
standards. Where operators
dontmake public disclosure
ofESG datathen we engage
withthem and encourage them
toadopt bestpractice.
Proven track record
The current management team has
worked together since 2014 and
consistently proven its ability to
deliver high quality transactions
and grow the Company.
Over $400m invested in growth
focused future facing commodity
assets over past four years.
$225m
Size of Revolving Credit
Facility ($150m) and
Accordion ($75m)
$75m
Net debt at end of 2023
>$400m
deployed over past
fouryears
Read more on p42 Read more on p50 Read more on p22
12.3
Sustainalytics score
15Ecora Resources PLC Annual Report and Accounts 2023
Strategic report Governance report Financial statements
CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER’S STATEMENT
Challenging global macroeconomic conditions persisted
throughout 2023. Contractionary monetary policies appear
tobesuccessfullycontaininginflationarypressures,
however fears of a hard economic landing persist.
As is always the case for the natural resource sector, demand
iskey. In this respect a slowdown in the Chinese economy
coupled with two serious international conflicts created a lot
ofuncertainty for domestic policies such as those around
adoption of electric vehicles and transition timelines and
commitments to net zero. This saw a reduction in demand
forelectric vehicles in certain markets which coincided with
increased supply of key battery commodities such as nickel.
However, lower commodity prices are likely to make certain
battery chemistries more economical with the potential of
lowering the cost of adoption – which in its own right could
trigger renewed demand in future periods.
These challenges were exacerbated by a noticeable stagnation
in the UK’s small-cap equity markets. This sector experienced
widespread redemptions across small-cap equity funds,
coupled with a notable shift of capital away from the UK.
The cumulative impact of these top-down factors have made
for a difficult year, particularly for UK listed small cap equities
and contributed to a 33% decline in our share price.
We look forward with confidence and in 2024 we anticipate
year-on-year production volume growth from the key assets
underlying our royalty portfolio, and in the medium term
onwards, our royalty portfolio is aligned to strong multi-decade
structural demand growth trends driven by the energy
transition. The investment in Ecora shares by the Ecora
Executive team, and along with several Board members
throughout 2023 and into 2024 demonstrates our belief in
Ecora’s solid foundation and promising future.
Growth opportunity
The mining sector at large has been facing the same challenging
market conditions that have impacted the Ecora share price.
The availability of capital from equity markets is primarily
limited to the largest producers. Furthermore, equity valuations
are compressed. In these conditions, however, royalty funding
is a highly attractive source of funding. Should these conditions
persist, we anticipate a favourable window to deploy capital
andfurther diversify and grow our royalty portfolio.
In 2023, Ecora made two development stage investments.
Wewere delighted to add a royalty over the Vizcachitas project,
one of the largest undeveloped copper projects that is not in
the hands of one of the large mining companies. As such, it was
a rare opportunity and adding it to our portfolio extends our
royalty sector leading copper growth pipeline out into the
nextdecade.
We were also pleased to make a further $7.5m investment into
Brazilian Nickels Piauí project. The proceeds will primarily be
used to finance detailed engineering studies and flow sheet
optimisation that will further de-risk the project prior to the
start of construction. Once built, the operation is expected to
be amongst the lowest cost global producers of nickel and
generate strong cash flows throughout the commodity
pricecycle.
During the year, we also reviewed and progressed a number of
opportunities across a variety of commodities and jurisdictions,
some of which we ultimately decided not to pursue. Asimportant
as the investments we make are the ones which we do not. Our
due diligence process is rigorous and looking back with hindsight
at these opportunities, the decisions taken were the correct
ones and have enabled us to preserve capital which can be
deployed in 2024. Our disciplined approach to investments
hasserved us well, and we will continue this diligent approach
to deliver on our strategy.
We look out to 2024
with a great deal
ofoptimism”
Marc Bishop Lafleche
Chief Executive Officer
16 Ecora Resources PLC Annual Report and Accounts 2023
Capital allocation
In light of current market conditions driving strong
mining sector demand for royalty financing, I believe it is
the right time to rebalance our capital allocation policy
towards growth while currently maintaining an attractive
dividend yield in the context of the wider royalty sector.
By adopting this framework, we are prioritising
accelerated diversification and scale, both crucial
prerequisites for a royalty company to achieve a
premium equity rating. In Q4 2023, we sold
approximately 60% of our stake in Labrador Iron Ore
Royalty Corporation (LIORC) realising C$18.9m, a total
pre-tax return on investment of c. 110%. these funds will
primarily fund the buyback programme we announced
today and the $7.5m we invested into Piauí in December
2023 With Ecora shares trading at approximately at 0.5x
estimated net asset value (based on research analyst
consensus estimates), increased exposure to our
high-quality royalty portfolio is a highly attractive
investment which will drive earnings and NAV per
shareaccretion.
The completion of our revolving credit facility refinancing
in January 2024 maintains our strong financial position,
enabling us to further grow the company through
acquisitions of attractive royalties. In particular, we were
pleased to upsize the acquisition accordion feature to
$75m, in addition to the $150m headline availability.
Updated capital allocation framework
Pillars Philosophy
Growth
Acquire high quality royalties
tofurther diversify and grow
theportfolio
Deleveraging
Focus on post-transaction balance
sheet deleveraging
Cash dividends
Distribute semi-annual cash
dividends based on range of 25-35%
of free cash flow
Strategic share
buybacks
Consider strategic share buybacks
incontext of market price and NAV
Results
Portfolio contribution of $63.6m was, as expected, lower than
the prior year (2022: $143.2m) primarily as a result of lower
production out of the Groups private royalty area at Kestrel.
Adjusted earnings per share was $11.82c (2022: 37.55c).
Net debt increased to $75m (2022: $36m) as payments of $37m
were made to South32 as deferred consideration for the royalty
acquisition made in July 2022 and the Group made $27.5m of
royalty acquisitions.
Outlook
Looking ahead, we have a great deal of optimism. Production
volumes from Kestrel, Voisey’s Bay and Mantos Blancos are all
expected to be higher than in 2023 which, at year-to-date
commodity price levels, could result in year-on-year portfolio
contribution growth in 2024.
The ramp-up of production from the underground mine at
Voisey’s Bay is expected to commence in the second half of 2024
and should lead to year-on-year growth in the number of cobalt
deliveries going forward, as it reaches steady state production.
Whilst there has already been plenty of turbulence in the nickel
markets in early 2024, both West Musgrave and Piauí sit at the
lower end of the cost curve, were they in production, would be
expected to generate robust cashflows even at current nickel
price levels. BHP has stated that construction of West Musgrave
is 21 per cent complete and that it is reviewing the phasing of
capital expenditure around the project. Brazilian Nickel
continues to progress construction financing workstreams
tofund the full-scale production plant at Piauí and we expect
more news on this during the course of 2024.
In our copper portfolio, Capstone Copper plans to release
anupdated Feasibility Study on Santo Domingo by mid-year.
Commentary from Capstone suggests there are material
efficiency gains and volume upside from the integrated
development plan compared to the initial Feasibility Study
completed in 2018.
The core portfolio is well positioned to deliver income growth
inthe year ahead. Our new capital allocation policy and upsized
debt facility position us at the forefront of the favourable
market conditions to deploy capital and further diversify and
grow the portfolio.
Finally, I would like to extend our deepest gratitude to our
outgoing Chairman, Patrick Meier, for his leadership and
commitment to building a world class royalty company
throughout his tenure. During the time Patrick has been Chair,
Ecora has transformed, and has emerged in a stronger and
more resilient position than ever before.
Marc Bishop Lafleche
Chief Executive Officer
26 March 2024
17Ecora Resources PLC Annual Report and Accounts 2023
Strategic report Governance report Financial statements
Applying a proven
business model
Our business model is proven and offers low risk exposure
toanincreasingly important basket of commodities.
Investing in royalties
What is a royalty?
A form of financing. In its simplest form
the royalty company provides the mine
operator with an upfront payment and
inreturn receives a percentage of
revenue generated from production
atthe mine. A stream is similar but
instead of percentage of revenue,
theroyalty company has the right
tobuya percentage of production
atanagreed, discounted price.
Primary and secondary
Primary royalties are a direct investment
in the mine and require the royalty
company tonegotiate the royalty
agreement with the mine operator.
Asecondary royalty is an existing royalty
that the royalty company acquires
fromthe holder of the royalty rights.
Royalty
Ecora
Resources
<